diff --git a/playbooks/include/proxies-reverseproxy.yml b/playbooks/include/proxies-reverseproxy.yml
index a368d5e6ca..c03375d4dd 100644
--- a/playbooks/include/proxies-reverseproxy.yml
+++ b/playbooks/include/proxies-reverseproxy.yml
@@ -138,6 +138,13 @@
     website: paste.fedoraproject.org
     destname: sticky-notes
     proxyurl: "{{ varnish_url }}"
+    when: env != "staging"
+
+  - role: httpd/reverseproxy
+    website: paste.fedoraproject.org
+    destname: modernpaste
+    proxyurl: http://localhost:10055
+    when: env == "staging"
 
   - role: httpd/reverseproxy
     website: admin.fedoraproject.org
@@ -569,12 +576,6 @@
     proxyurl: http://localhost:10052
     when: env == "staging"
 
-  - role: httpd/reverseproxy
-    website: modernpaste.fedoraproject.org
-    destname: modernpaste
-    proxyurl: http://localhost:10055
-    when: env == "staging"
-
   - role: httpd/reverseproxy
     website: koji.fedoraproject.org
     destname: koji