diff --git a/roles/robosignatory/templates/robosignatory.toml.j2 b/roles/robosignatory/templates/robosignatory.toml.j2
index 6395d88b6e..40565cd009 100644
--- a/roles/robosignatory/templates/robosignatory.toml.j2
+++ b/roles/robosignatory/templates/robosignatory.toml.j2
@@ -313,6 +313,18 @@ handlers = ["console"]
 
             # Gated bodhi updates
 
+            [[consumer_config.koji_instances.primary.tags]]
+            from = "epel9-signing-pending"
+            to = "epel9-testing-pending"
+            key = "{{ (env == 'production')|ternary('epel-9', 'testkey') }}"
+            keyid = "{{ (env == 'production')|ternary('3228467c', 'd300e724') }}"
+
+            [[consumer_config.koji_instances.primary.tags]]
+            from = "epel9-next-signing-pending"
+            to = "epel9-next-testing-pending"
+            key = "{{ (env == 'production')|ternary('epel-9', 'testkey') }}"
+            keyid = "{{ (env == 'production')|ternary('3228467c', 'd300e724') }}"
+
             [[consumer_config.koji_instances.primary.tags]]
             from = "epel8-signing-pending"
             to = "epel8-testing-pending"